Blind Swords vs They March Against Us: systems compared

Blind Swords vs They March Against Us: systems compared

TL:DR or The short answer

TMAU is the direct descendant. Luttmann’s notes say he used “the DNA of Blind Swords to create the operational shell and then concentrate on how to make it unique – not just a carbon copy of its ACW sibling” (20.0). The skeleton is plain to see, I mean man, even I can see it !! 😊 .

Both have the same four Orders types, fire before movement, Key and random events, wild draws, a timed Broken Track , and Cohesion Tests banded similarly with – Routine/Tough/Severe by the target’s Cohesion Rating.

What changes is the scale (regiments to divisions), cards for chits, how damage is recorded, and the assault, which becomes a Napoleonic charge.

The changes are made to evoke the Napoleonic era. My game play will see how that all comes together!

1. Scale and counters

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• 1 SP = 50 men; regiment/battalion counters with a brigade band; artillery batteries or sections (2.1).

• Fresh and Battleworn sides; Fragile units have only a Battleworn side and are eliminated rather than Broken (2.1).

• Counter: SP, Weapon Type, Cohesion Rating; no MA, which comes from the Order (2.1).

• Two dice: one coloured, one white (2.7).

• 1 SP = about 500 men or 6 guns; divisions or large brigades; hex about 400 yards; turn about 1.5 hours (3.1).

• Deployed and Concentrated sides, not Fresh and Battleworn. Damage is tracked by Hit markers (4.1d–e, 4.2).

• Counter: Manpower SP, Artillery SP (light, plus a heavy ‘H’ value), MA, CR, nationality, army/wing/corps (4.1).

• Five dice each: black, white, red, blue d6 and a green d10 (4.6).

.

• Same: CR 0–6 as the unit’s quality, an 11–66 black/white or colour/white roll on the CRT. I don’t know why more people don’t use this style of CRT.
• Different: Ten times the men per SP. In TMAU the counter’s two sides are formation, not damage. TMAU puts the MA on the counter and lets the Order modify it; Blind Swords takes it wholly from the Order. TMAU infantry carries its own guns.

2. Sequence of play

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• 1 Command Decision. 2 Artillery Phase (sides alternate hexes: move or fire; then Artillery Rally). 3 Chit Draw. 4 Brigade Activation: Orders → Fire → Move → Close Combat → Rally. 5 End Turn (4.0).

• 1 Command Decision. 2 Card Draw. 3 Formation Activation: event resolved, then Fire → Move → Assault → Rally. 4 End Phase (6.0).

.

               

• Same: Same activation spine. Both stress that fire comes before movement (BS 4.0; TMAU 6.0).
• Different: TMAU has no separate Artillery Phase. Guns activate with their formation or fire from inside an infantry division. TMAU also has no Orders Step: the Order comes printed on the activation card (8.3a).

3. Command and activation

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Chits in a cup: Division, Brigade and CIC Activation chits, each with a Command Rating; Event chits; two Wild chits (2.4, 5.3).

• Division chit: roll one die vs Command Rating. Pass = one brigade gets a Full Activation; fail = Limited Activation, fire only. The chit returns to the cup while brigades remain (7.3).

• CIC chit: activate any one brigade, even one already used (7.3).

• Orders chosen when the brigade activates (8.1).

• Held chits: Events and CIC, any number, played before each draw (7.1).

• Cards in a deck: Formation Activation cards per French wing (ten each) and Allied army (six each), CIC cards, Event cards, two Wild cards, Scenario cards (4.4, 7.1).

• Players choose which Activation cards go in, and so which Orders, before the turn (7.1).

• Card drawn: roll black/white (11–66) on the card to see how many units, corps or wings activate. Doubles give bonus units or a different Order (8.3a).

• Ney, Murat and Silesia cards let one extra unit assault or move (8.3a). Guard corps move only on the Napoleon card or certain events (8.3b).

• Hold up to two cards of any kind, Activation cards included; holding a third means discarding one (8.1).

.

• Same: Both sides’ activations and events mixed in one random draw; a leader-quality die roll scales the activation; CIC cards that reach across the army; held cards.
• Different: Blind Swords activates a brigade at a time, with a pass/fail on Command Rating. TMAU activates a slice of a wing or army, sized by an 11–66 roll on the card. Blind Swords picks the Order on activation. TMAU commits to it before the turn: “The system simply forces the players to commit to a set of orders at the start of the game turn” (20.0). TMAU lets you hold an activation card to time it (8.1). Luttmann: “The cards replace the chits used in the ACW Blind Swords series, and this allows for more flexibility in their utility” (20.0).

.

4. Events and wild draws

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Key Chits picked, then random events drawn blind; the rest excluded this turn (5.1–5.2).

• Fortunes of War chit: the next chit drawn is negated (7.3a).

• Fog of War chit: one die on a game-specific table (7.3b).

• No Default Event in the series rules.

• Key Event cards picked, then random events drawn blind (7.2–7.3).

• Friction of War card: the next CIC card leaves for the turn, the next Formation card gets its worst result, the next Event is discarded (8.3d).

• Fortunes of War card: roll 11–66 on its own table (8.3e).

• Default Event on every Event card: Opportunity Fire at an adjacent unit, or Steal a March: move one unit, both as if under Attack (8.3c).

.

• Same: Key plus random events chosen the same way; one wild that spoils the next draw, one that rolls on a table.
• Different: The two wild names swap jobs. Blind Swords’ Fortunes of War negates the next draw. In TMAU, Friction of War does that and Fortunes of War is the table roll. TMAU adds the Default Event.

5. Orders — same four names

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Attack: Engage, fire, Close Combat; no Rally, no March Column (8.2).

• Defend: Engage, fire only; Rally (8.3).

• Maneuver: no Engagement, no combat of any kind; the only Order with March Column (8.4).

• Regroup: no movement, no combat; full Rally (8.5).

• Movement allowances on each game’s player aid (8.2–8.4).

• Attack: printed MA, Engage, fire and Assault; no Rally (9.1).

• Defend: MA −2, Engage, fire with a right shift, Rally (9.2).

• Maneuver: MA +2, Road March Bonus, no Engagement, may fire with a left shift, no Rally (9.3).

• Regroup: one hex only, may change formation, fire with a left shift, Rally at +1 CR (9.4).

.

• Same: The same four Orders with the same intent.
• Different: TMAU loosens Maneuver and Regroup so both can still shoot, at a penalty, and lets Regroup creep one hex. Blind Swords forbids both outright.

6. Fire combat

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Target is a hex; the largest-SP unit is the Lead Unit and takes the test (9.1, 9.2).

• One CRT, columns C to 23+ (9.3).

• Range cuts SP: Effective full, Long half, Extreme quarter; Canister +50% (9.1c).

• Optional combining: infantry in one hex or two adjacent hexes of one brigade (9.1e).

• Roll 1: CRT colour band by Lead Unit CR (Routine/Tough/Severe). Roll 2: coloured die = Depletion Test, white die = Skedaddle Test (9.3, 12.1).

• Flanking Fire: one right shift when fire lines are separated by at least a hexside (9.3c).

• Firing does not stop movement or Close Combat (8.3 note).

• Target is one enemy unit, the Target Unit (10.1).

• Two CRTs, Artillery Bombardment and Infantry Volley, columns C to 32+ (10.2, 10.3).

• Range by weapon: muskets adjacent only; light guns two hexes; heavy guns three; canister two right shifts (10.1c).

• Compulsory combining: same-corps units stacked or adjacent firing at one target must combine, any number (10.2e).

• One roll of five dice: black/white gives the colour band by the target’s CR; red die = Hits; blue die = Retreat; green d10 = Combat Event on doubles (10.4).

• Enfilade Fire: a right shift when fire lines are separated by a full hex (10.3d).

• Firing halves the unit’s movement in the same activation (10.2b–c, 11.3c).

.

• Same: CR-banded test colours, a two-part effect (one die for losses, one for falling back), a bonus for converging fire, the C column.

.

• Different: TMAU folds the two Blind Swords rolls into one throw: the red die does what the coloured Depletion die did, and the blue does what the white Skedaddle die did. It fires at a unit, not a hex, so there’s no Lead Unit. It splits musket from cannon, makes same-corps fire compulsory, and charges movement for shooting.

7. Movement and engagement

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Minimum move of one hex always (10.3).

• Stacks may move together (10.4).

• Roads 1 MP; March Column 1/2 MP on roads/turnpikes under Maneuver or for artillery (10.5).

• Leaving a hex next to the enemy draws Opportunity Fire at half SP from every adjacent enemy (10.7).

• Artillery may not voluntarily come within two hexes of the enemy (6.5, 10.6).

• Cavalry withdraws as the enemy closes; mounts or dismounts for 3 MP; can make a Charge Move in clear terrain for +2 shifts (10.8–10.10).

• Cavalry may not stack with infantry or artillery (3.1b).

• No minimum move (11.1).

• Units move one at a time (11.1).

• Roads 1 MP for Concentrated units only; under Maneuver, three consecutive road hexes free (11.5).

• Engaging or Disengaging costs +1 MP; no fire. A unit that becomes Engaged can ‘bounce off’ but not slide along the enemy line (11.4b).

• No artillery distance rule in the rulebook.

• Change of Formation halves MA (with a Morale Test if Engaged); Square for infantry (11.3a–b).

• Stacking 20 SP; no cavalry stacking ban (5.0).

.

• Same: Order-driven speed, a faster road rate reserved for Maneuver, a cost for coming into or leaving contact.
• Different: TMAU drops Opportunity Fire. Contact now costs movement points only, because at division scale the skirmish friction “is not enough to cause any casualties” (11.4b). Blind Swords’ dismounting cavalry becomes TMAU’s line, column and square.

8. Close combat becomes the Napoleonic charge

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Declare attacks; defenders fire, and other adjacent defenders not themselves attacked add Supporting Defensive Fire at half SP (11.2–11.3a).

• Mounted cavalry may withdraw from an infantry attack instead of firing (11.3b).

• Several attacking hexes: one Assaulting Hex sets the column; Flanking Hexes count only for Out Numbering (11.3c).

• The attacker rolls once; every result goes to the Close Combat Cohesion Test Table; a ‘–’ is a Close Fight that can hurt both sides (11.0, 12.2).

• Either side may Advance After Close Combat, two hexes if the loser fled two or broke (12.7).

• Declare Charges; infantry and cavalry may not charge the same hex together (12.1–12.2).

• Charge Morale Test per attacker: Confident, normal, Hesitant or no charge. −1 CR if an unengaged enemy hex is next to it (Defensive Support) (12.3).

• Hold Morale Test per defender: infantry hit by cavalry must form square; cavalry charged by infantry makes the infantry call it off; failing defenders fall back before contact (12.4).

• Defenders that hold fire Defensive Fire (12.5).

• Both sides roll on the Infantry or Cavalry Assault CRT; results crossed on a matrix; matching results = Close Fight, read off each side’s red die (12.6).

• Infantry may advance; cavalry must advance and test for Impetus, up to a ‘Bloodlust’ charge (12.6h–i).

.

• Same: Commit-then-resolve, the defender shoots before contact, a Close Fight that can bloody both sides, advance into the vacated hex, cavalry that can step back from infantry.
• Different: TMAU adds a morale gate on each side before anyone touches. Luttmann says it is “reminiscent of a miniatures style of sequencing” (20.0). Blind Swords’ Supporting Defensive Fire turns into a −1 CR on the charger’s test. One attacker roll becomes both sides rolling, with separate infantry and cavalry tables.

9. Damage, morale and the Broken Track

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Damage = Depletion (flip to Battleworn) plus Morale Hits: Shaken (−1 SP, −1 CR), Disrupted (−2/−2) (12.1, 12.5).

• A Depletion on a Battleworn unit or a hit on a Disrupted one forces a Break Test; the margin of failure sets Broken Box 1, 2 or 3 (12.6).

• Unit Support: −1 CR without a sound same-brigade unit stacked or adjacent (12.4).

• Panic results pick low-CR units nearby to take a hit and retreat (12.1b).

• Artillery and Fragile units are eliminated, never placed on the track (12.8).

• Damage = Hit markers on a ladder: 1 Shaken, 2 Disrupted (−1 CR), 3 Depleted (−1 CR), 4 Battleworn (−2 CR) (4.2).

• A unit Breaks when its Hits reach its size threshold (3/4/5); every Hit beyond that pushes it one box deeper (4.3).

• No Unit Support; only the ‘Supported’ check on one Volley result (10.4b).

• A unit breaking in a stack makes its stack-mates take a Panic test (10.4b).

• Artillery and cavalry count as Small units and go on the Broken Track like infantry (4.1, 4.3).

• Morale Test: one die vs CR. Under = Pass, equal = Nervous, over or a 6 = Fail (15.1).

.

• Same: Broken Track with boxes 3-2-1-Available, stepping down each End Phase (BS 12.8, 14.4; TMAU 17.0, 14.2). Shaken and Disrupted survive as names.
• Different: Blind Swords’ damage vocabulary becomes TMAU’s single counted ladder: Shaken, Disrupted, Depleted, Battleworn. The Break Test is replaced by fixed thresholds. Unit Support goes, along with the cohesion-by-neighbour idea. Which I believe is the same or similar to how Black Swan [AMFS] describes state.

.

10. Rally — the Blind Swords optional rule made standard

Blind Swords (ACW, chits)

They March Against Us (Napoleonic, cards)

• Rally under Defend or Regroup, three hexes clear: Recovery removes one Morale Hit (Defend) or all (Regroup); Rebuild (Regroup only) flips to Fresh or returns an Available unit (13.1–13.2).

• Optional: a unit back from the Broken Track should never return to Fresh, but “it is not possible within the physical constraints of the game package to provide markers to keep track of such units” (13.2).

• Rally under Regroup or Defend, not adjacent: a Morale Test removes one Hit, or brings one unit back from ‘Available’ (13.0–13.3).

• A returned unit gets Critical Hit markers; its Shaken one “can never be removed”. Break it again and it is Shattered, gone for good (4.2, 4.3, 13.3).

.

• Same: Rally is tied to Defend/Regroup and distance from the enemy; broken units return weakened.
• Different: TMAU’s Critical Hit marker is the marker Blind Swords said it couldn’t fit in the box. The optional rule is now standard, and it adds the Shattered result.

11. Only in one of them

Only in Blind Swords’ series rules:

• Separate alternating Artillery Phase and Artillery Rally (6.0–6.4).
• Limited Activation (fire only) on a failed Command Rating roll (7.3).
• Lead Unit (9.2); range by SP fraction (9.1c).
• Opportunity Fire on leaving contact (10.7).
• Cavalry mount/dismount, Charge Move, withdrawal as the enemy approaches, and stacking ban (10.8–10.10, 3.1b).
• Unit Support (12.4); Break Test (12.6); Fragile units (2.1).
• Supporting Defensive Fire (11.3a); Flanking Hexes and Out Numbering (11.3c).
• Permanent off-map exit (10.12).

Only in They March Against Us:

• Cards and order commitment at seeding; holding activation cards (7.1, 8.1).
• Default Event (8.3c).
• Deployed/Concentrated formation and Square (4.1d–e, 11.3).
• Attached artillery and heavy-gun long range (4.1j, 10.1c).
• Separate Artillery Bombardment, Infantry Volley, Infantry Assault and Cavalry Assault CRTs (4.5).
• Charge and Hold Morale Tests; Confident and Hesitant charges; Cavalry Impetus (12.3, 12.4, 12.6i).
• Hit-marker ladder, Critical Hits, Shattered units (4.2–4.3).
• Dawn, Dusk, Overnight and Lull Days; French-only Fieldworks and Fortified hexes (18.0, 11.8–11.9).
• Imperial Guard command lock; Cossacks; Rotha off-map crossing (8.3b, 8.3g, 11.7).

12. Bottom line

TMAU is Blind Swords with the frame left standing and the parts swapped for the period and the scale. Kept in place: the four Orders, fire before movement, the event-seeding ritual, the wild draws, the CR-banded Cohesion Tests, and the Broken Track.

Changed: chits to cards [ala Black Swan style] with orders written in advance; regiments to divisions carrying their own guns; Fresh/Battleworn to Deployed/Concentrated plus a hit ladder; Opportunity Fire to a movement cost. The biggest change is that an ACW firefight becomes a Napoleonic charge, decided by nerve before contact.

Luttmann took the same Blind Swords frame two ways. For a bigger ACW battle (AMFS) he scaled up the command chain and the pinning game. For the Napoleonic era (TMAU) he put the period into the counter and the moment of contact.

.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.