Das Reich pushed back toward Kharkov

Von Manstein’s Backhand Blow (GMT, 2002) — turn-to-history

Campaign game: 31 January – 22 March 1943 · 17 turns · 3 days per turn.

I’m preparing to write the AAR for turns 6,7 and onwards and we have kind of slacked off on the step loss counting. So I did some diggin on what happened and when….
I suck as the Soviets!!

Maybe we use this to score the session against the real operation as we play.

North-west of Kharkov during Turn 4

Every event is sourced, is the compressed table.

Reading it: the right-hand column is the historical benchmark for that turn. If Kharkov falls  Turn 12, you are three turns ahead of Manstein. If it hasn’t fallen by Turn 16, you are behind him and running out of game.
As We know turn 5 I was barely getting going and no attacks on Kharkv have happened!Turn 6 Kharkov falls.
Here is the problem I suspect, I’ve been husbanding C3i points to use during the turns when there are NO – significant C3i pts to be had. But even then, I cannot see with this game how you get units into – at Kharkov by turn 6.

Seeing the run rate, its starting to make me wonder about historical fidelity.

.

Turn

Dates

What actually happened

1

31 Jan – 2 Feb

Paulus surrenders 31 Jan; northern pocket 2 Feb. Gallop already running (from 29 Jan). Star opens 2 Feb. Rybalko tears open 298th Infantry’s flanks

2

3 – 5 Feb

Germans read Soviet intentions from prisoners and air recce; Popov’s group identified. Izyum falls 5 Feb

3

6 – 8 Feb

Manstein at the Wolfsschanze, 6 Feb — wins the Mius withdrawal and gets 4th Panzer Army released from Rostov. The decision that makes everything later possible

4

9 – 11 Feb

Rybalko forces the Donets, takes Chuguyev (10 Feb). 11 Feb: Grishino and Krasnoarmeiskoye taken — Manstein’s lateral railway cut

5

12 – 14 Feb

Direct assault on Kharkov from NE and E. Army group HQ to Zaporozhye; Army Group Don becomes Army Group South (13 Feb). 14 Feb: Hausser’s first withdrawal order

6

15 – 17 Feb

⚑ KHARKOV LOST. SS Panzer Corps evacuates 15 Feb, Soviets occupy on the 16th. Hitler arrives at Zaporozhye 17 Feb. Pavlograd falls; Soviet spearheads ~20 miles from the Dnepr

7

18 – 20 Feb

⚑ THE COUNTERSTROKE OPENS. 18 Feb XL Panzer Corps attacks behind snowploughs, astride Popov’s supply lines within hours. 19 Feb 15th Infantry detrains straight into Sinelnikovo and retakes it. 20 Feb Hoth opens the counteroffensive proper. Lanz relieved, Kempf takes over

8

21 – 23 Feb

Vatutin refuses Popov permission to withdraw (21 Feb). Pavlograd taken 22 Feb. 23 Feb XLVIII Panzer Corps strikes north and cuts I Guards and XXV Tank Corps’ communications

9

24 – 26 Feb

24 Feb: Vatutin finally halts all offensive operations. Lozovaya fought 25–26 Feb. 26 Feb: Eicke killed, Priess takes SS-Totenkopf

10

27 Feb – 1 Mar

Lozovaya taken 27 Feb; Barvenkovo bypassed. 28 Feb the Donets reached on a broad front. 1 Mar Moskalenko permitted to go over to the defensive

11

2 – 4 Mar

3rd Tank Army destroyed. 2 Mar Rybalko attacks with ~30 tanks into Totenkopf coming the other way and is encircled. 3 Mar Koptsov mortally wounded in the breakout. Vatutin’s right wing back over the Donets

12

5 – 7 Mar

5 Mar: Rybalko has no tanks left. ⚑ 6 Mar: the drive on Kharkov begins — Manstein’s explicit order is defeat the defenders, then bypass the city to the west. 7 Mar AA Kempf joins with Grossdeutschland

13

8 – 10 Mar

8 Mar Taranovka and Sokolovo — the Czechoslovak battalion stops them cold in street fighting. 9 Mar: Hausser orders a direct assault on the city without confirming with Hoth. 10 Mar Hitler’s second Zaporozhye visit; Kursk raised as a summer objective

14

11 – 13 Mar

Bogodukhov taken 11 Mar. Hoth orders Das Reich out of the city; Hausser objects and prevaricates until written orders arrive on the 12th. A third of Kharkov held by day’s end. 13 Mar: fuel and roads stop Totenkopf closing the eastern envelopment — the garrison escapes

15

14 – 16 Mar

⚑ KHARKOV RETAKEN. SS declare the city taken after dusk on 14 Mar (Buttar, Forczyk); Jukes and Carell say 15 Mar; Glantz says 16 Mar — all three fall inside this turn. 16 Mar the spearheads meet SE of the city: seven rifle divisions and two tank corps wrecked. Borisovka tank action

16

17 – 19 Mar

⚑ BELGOROD, 18 Mar — Buttar, Glantz, Jukes and the Soviet official history all agree. (Forczyk alone says 16 Mar, which would put it in Turn 15 — he’s the outlier)

17

20 – 22 Mar

22 Mar: Raus’s infantry reach Belgorod as the thaw begins in earnest. Both sides stop. The line is back almost exactly where it was a year before — with a large Soviet salient around Kursk

.

One thought on “Von Manstein’s Backhand Blow (GMT, 2002) — turn-to-history”

  1. I absolutely love this as a gaming approach, especially for playing solo. These games are ideal teaching aids for history and understanding the various campaigns and battles.

    And I dare say that, when designing games, one must take pains to be sure that the historical result is possible, if not probable. Players should still be able to “change history” and reverse outcomes, but the actual result should still be more likely than not. It’s a fine line to create an interesting and challenging game without just a “replay of events”, such as you surmised with Operation Typhoon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.