SPI’s Operation Typhoon: No Overrun, No Decision

The awesome blog Map & Counters revisited: Joe’s 2009 profile of Joseph Angiolillo’s Operation Typhoon, I set that against what the wargame magazines said when the game was new, and what happened when it went on the table as  solo plays and 4 man opposed play.

The battle: 15 November – 5 December 1941

Operation Typhoon opened on 1 October 1941 and stalled in the autumn mud. The game covers its second act. Army Group Centre resumed the offensive on 15 November, once the ground had frozen hard (Glantz, p. 169). In the north, Third Panzer Group took Klin on 23 November. By the night of 28 November it had reached the Moscow–Volga Canal at Iakhroma, less than 35 km from the Kremlin. On 30 November Fourth Panzer Group took Krasnaia Poliana, within artillery range of the city (Glantz, p. 172).

In the south, Guderian’s Second Panzer Army pushed past Tula toward Venev and Kashira. Belov’s improvised cavalry corps drove back its spearhead, 17th Panzer Division, on 27 November (Glantz, pp. 172–174). Kluge’s Fourth Army made a last frontal attack at Naro-Fominsk on 1 December and was back on its start line within two days (Glantz, pp. 175–176). By 5 December both panzer groups had stopped 15–28 km short of Moscow’s main defence lines. On 4 December the temperature fell to −35°C (Glantz, pp. 176–177).

The counteroffensive began on 5 December on the Kalinin Front and spread south over the following days (Glantz, p. 189). The Osprey Zhukov volume gives the same shape: the German offensive resumed on 15 November, culminated about 12 miles from the Kremlin as winter arrived, and Zhukov and Konev counterattacked on 5 December (Osprey Command 22, pp. 21–22). Glantz puts German casualties for the October–November lunge at 145,000, and Red Army losses far higher (p. 182).

Identity card

◦ Title: Operation Typhoon: The German Assault on Moscow, 1941
◦ Publisher: Simulations Publications, Inc. (SPI), 1978. Large “soap-box” monster-game box (Joe).
◦ Design: Joseph Angiolillo. Development: Joseph M. Balkoski (Moves 46; S&T 100). S&T 65 first listed Hessel as developer; S&T 66 shows Balkoski.
◦ System: adapted from Wacht am Rhein, with Panzergruppe Guderian’s limited intelligence (Joe; Phoenix 19; Moves 36).
◦ Scale: one day per turn; about 2.7 miles per hex (Joe) or “approximately two and one-half miles” (S&T 69 ad); regiments and divisions, with battalions.
◦ Maps and counters: three 22″ x 34″ maps, 800 counters (Joe).
◦ Scenarios: three 16-turn single-map scenarios (Guderian at Tula, Hoepner toward Moscow, von Kluge on the Nara) plus a campaign game, extendable to 15 December (S&T 69 ad; Wargamer 1.10).
◦ Price and release: $20; advertised for 28 August 1978 (S&T 69). S&T 71 reported production ran six weeks late, with release “momentarily”.

Witness 1: Joe, Map & Counters (May 2009)

Joe called it “a reasonably historical simulation” with components that are “colorful, clear, and generally nicely done”, credited to Redmond Simonsen. He still reached for SPI’s older Moscow Campaign (1972) whenever he wanted to refight the battle.

He named two reasons. First, the support rules place “relatively severe restrictions” on German operations. Second, the time window shuts out Zhukov’s counteroffensive unless both players agree to play on. His verdict was “a weak recommendation”: a buy for a dedicated East Front collector. He pointed Wacht am Rhein fans to Jack Radey’s Korsun Pocket (1979) instead. He rated solitaire suitability as low.

In a companion post comparing SPI’s three Moscow games (1970, 1972, 1978), he granted Typhoon the best graphics but kept The Moscow Campaign as his favourite.

Witness 2: SPI itself, before release (1977–78)

Joseph Balkoski previewed the game in Moves 36 (Dec 1977/Jan 1978). He described it as an outside design built on Wacht am Rhein. He said Angiolillo’s research drew largely on primary sources: German Lage Ost daily situation maps from the National Archives, used for both sides’ divisions and their order of appearance.

SPI’s ad in S&T 69 (Jul/Aug 1978) promised “the first of the truly playable SPI ‘monster’ games”, with a campaign game that “can be completed in one day”.

.

Witness 3: Friedrich G. Helfferich, Fire & Movement 15 (February 1979)

Under the title “Fury Long Since Spent”, Helfferich praised the system as “refreshingly uncomplicated, sound, and easy to learn”. He called the random strength chits “a clever device”, but he was hard on the rulebook:

“The rules are 24 pages long only because they say in ten words what could be said in three, and repeat it twice for good measure.”

He also faulted the maps and the weather rules. On top of the weather, the supply rules leave the Germans with only about half their forces in supply at any time. He doubted the Germans could win “given average luck”, adding: “But then, they had not much chance in November 1941 either.” His close:

“If you relish seeing the last round of a heavy-weight match with both fighters stumbling on the verge of collapse, you’ll probably love Typhoon.”

Witness 4: Brian Laidlaw, Phoenix 19 (UK, 1979)

Laidlaw wrote the longest piece, four pages, and the warmest: “a damn fine wargame”, “‘clean’ manageable and often fascinating”, though not one to recommend unreservedly. He called weather and supply the two critical rules. He judged the weather rules “the Achilles Heel”: snow can vanish overnight and frozen rivers can flow freely again the next day. He found only about half the German army at full strength at any one time, because of the support rules.

He played the extended campaign to turn 25 and stopped, because the rules gave him no way to score the result. He flagged a missing victory-point rule and hoped for errata. He also reported that Angiolillo’s designer’s notes “read almost in the nature of an apology”: the designer felt the SPI feedback poll had forced him to start the game midway through the operation. Unlike Joe, Laidlaw found the game “functions very well as a solitaire exercise”.

Witness 5: Wargamer Vol. 1 No. 10 (UK; reviewer not identified)

The reviewer’s name does not survive in the scanned text. The verdict: “an interesting game, and worth the trip through entangled rules”. The criticisms were rule overlap and needless repetition. Rule 17.1’s air-point allocation is contradicted by three of the four scenarios, and the support rules should have been folded into supply. The praise went to the limited-intelligence system, “sure to be copied again and again”, and the German player’s secret choice of plan, with victory conditions revealed only at the end. The reviewer argued that starting on 1 September would have needed far more map or a smaller scale, “So we have Operation Typhoon, take it or leave it.”

Consensus and conflict

Where the witnesses agree:

• The time window. Joe, Helfferich, Laidlaw and the Wargamer reviewer all note that the game covers only the November push. Laidlaw says the designer agreed.
• German support and supply. Every witness finds the German player able to attack with only part of the army at any one time. Joe dislikes it; Laidlaw and Helfferich treat it as the history.
• The rules writing. Helfferich and Wargamer both attack the 24-page rulebook. Laidlaw points to the missing victory-point rule.
• The weather rules. Laidlaw and Helfferich both call them flawed.
• Limited intelligence. Praised by Helfferich, Laidlaw and Wargamer.

Where they split:

• Solitaire. Joe rates it low; Laidlaw says it works very well.
• Overall. Joe gives a weak recommendation and prefers the 1972 game. Laidlaw calls it a damn fine wargame. Helfferich says you’ll love it if you like a last round between two exhausted fighters.
• Campaign end. Joe says a regular game ends 15 December. SPI’s ad and Wargamer describe a campaign to about 1 December, extendable to 15 December.

Canon vs table: my game (2012)

Overall my opposed and solo plays ran the gamut of emotions, many echoed above by other reviewers!

Learning the combat system, solo (“Operation Typhoon Learning Combat”, blog, 24 May 2012)

“As a brief experiment with how combat will, or could work I ran thru turn one one Map C. In essence 24th Corps opening turn.”

“The rest were a disaster! Looking for a quick VPs, I piled onto Tula. Only to find a tough defense backed up by air to counter my air and +4 shifts! Units with 12 defense! 18 defense! OMG. Meanwhile the Axis pulled 5’s, 4’s, and even a 1.”

“Second time around, new chits etc, and another ass whipping ( well ok, so it was 2 steps lost each side and one less retreat) for the Germans. Ok..Ok. I get it. Let us not rush to our deaths here.”

“The random strength thing is not going to let you estimate potential strengths. Too many variables! Love it. There will be no perfect turns here.”

 

 

 

The solo campaign and the weather error (“In the Confession booth over Operation Typhoon”, blog, 2012)

Full Playlist: 

 

“Lets talk about the semantic difference between Precipitation and Snow. NONE both are precipitation. READ THE RULES MORON….. Snow of course is a type of precipitation. I was ‘reading’ it as rain. Why I will never know.”

“We had precipitation, i.e. we had snow…. This matters, as movement and combat factors are halved for all Germans, but not for most of the Russians.”

“I am in start of turn 17, thus potentially wiping 5 played turns out [ick], and what will be/would have been an unearned Decisive German Victory, due to the weather error.”

“Overall the Soviets have lost 57 VPs to date, 25 of which are City hex vps at the start of Turn 17. The German fighting force is in good shape with very few reduced Divisions, and only 1-2 Tank Battalions lost.”

“Due to in part to my posts, friends have rallied to offer to REBOOT with me from scratch! … We will also use Nathan Kilgores suggested optional rules.”

The four-player game (“Getting started Op Typhoon” and “Post Mortem 4man Op Typhoon”, blog, 24 June 2012)

“Agreed : All optional Rules. All Errata and suggested edits to rules and VC per BGG. NOT using V2 rules. Saving that for a comparison play!”

“Brady and Kevin Evil Empire #1 Germans v Cisco and Peter, Evil Empire #2”

“The two least experienced players myself and Brady had the task of capturing Moscow. We actually decided to go the encirclement route with Kilgores modified rules and errata.”

“Our first mistake was to allow me any points for support for the 3rd Panzer Army. We should have left it with zero points and let it shuffle forward unsupported and out of supply and allocated that extra support point to one of Brady’s armies, for the first 5 turns, especially given what happened.”

“Tula held for 4 turns. On the 5th turn we had a net 16 VPs.”

 

Solo play .

“By the end of turn 7 however this was the result: net 31 VPS including Tula (10) + 6 cities. 19 regiments or Bns lost by Germany. 25 Brigades or Divisions lost by Soviets. 13 Fresh Divisions about to enter!”

“So after looking hard at our potential to break thru and do some damage, we agreed that the South was spent. The North was ok but challenged by a deepening defense and bad terrain.”

Cisco, the northern Soviet player, added to the same post:

“The thing about this game is there really isn’t any overrun capability. So that means even a 1 point unit can limit panzer divisions to a one hex advance. By putting weak road blocks in front of “schwerpunkt”s, the concentrated German drives can be blunted.”

“Maybe it would have been better to have like 10 attacks around 6-1, rather than have 4 attacks at 9-1, a turn.”

“…the way I’ve played that area before was to bypass Tula, leaving it surrounded with mediocre troops, and using the panzer divisions to try to trap Russians. Clear out the area, then deal with Tula later.”

• Weather. I missed two snow turns (12 and 16) and the Germans ran east unchecked. Laidlaw called the weather rules the “Achilles Heel”; my game shows how much hangs on them.
• No exploitation. Cisco’s “no overrun” matches Helfferich’s complaint about the “absence of an exploitation phase”. Laidlaw reached the same answer from the German side: settle for small pockets and “short sharp disabling shock attacks”. Cisco’s “10 attacks around 6-1” says much the same. It becomes easy as the Soviet to just blunt the advance along forested roads to one hex a turn. – Jam crap units into the meat grinder. That kinda breaks the game for me. There is no ability to be decisive.
• Tula. Laidlaw opened with an accelerated assault on Tula and was stuck there for several turns. My first solo test piled onto Tula and failed. Cisco’s advice is to bypass it.
• Support. My “zero points to 3rd Panzer” lesson is the support rule Joe disliked, seen from the inside.

.

these are old vids! apologies for the shakey cam!

.

Solitaire. I played it solo first afew times, then four-handed. That puts me as I said at the top between Joe (“low”) and Laidlaw (“very well”). I think its interesting game.
OVERALL:
The game flows pretty well, we had fun opposed, but weather, rando combat capability of your best Tank formations and the one hex advance bump stop the Soviets can play, really put a damper on the ‘excitment’ of closing in on some form of victory as the Germans. For the Soviets pushing the odd units into the tracks of an advancing panzer can derive only so much joy for so long.  You  will achieve a historical result. You may grow to not like the experience over repeated plays.
I would not buy the rebooted new Decision Games version. After several plays of this…. I am at quota in the cold at the gates to Moscow.

The videos from that play, 26 May – 24 June 2012:

Uploaded

Title

Link

2012-05-26

SPI Typhoon

2012-05-27

Operation Typhoon REBOOT_Turn1

2012-05-28

Operation Typhoon T2 German results. SPI

2012-05-28

Operation Typhoon Turn 8 Breakthru! North of Moscow

2012-05-29

Operation Typhoon _Turn 2 Campaign. SPI

2012-05-29

SPI Operation Typhoon Turn 3

2012-05-29

Operation Typhoon T3 Sov

2012-05-30

Operation Typhoon Turn 4 support allocation

2012-05-30

SPI Operation Typhoon Turn 5

2012-05-31

Operation TyphoonTurn5_end turn summary

2012-06-01

Supply in Operation Typhoon

2012-06-01

SPI Operation Typhoon Turn 6

2012-06-03

SPI Operation Typhoon Turn 7

2012-06-07

SPI Operation Typhoon Turn6 G

2012-06-07

Operation Typhoon Turn 7 & VC conditions

2012-06-08

Operation Typhoon End 14 notes

2012-06-15

Operation Typhoon, SPI session : endturn12-

2012-06-21

operation typhoon turn 16. SPI

2012-06-24

live Turns 1-4 Operation Typhoon

2012-06-24

Operation Typhoon live Turn 6

.

Sources

• Joe, Map & Counters, “SPI, Operation Typhoon (1978)”, May 2009 (archive: 05_REFERENCE_LIBRARY/mapandcounters-blog/posts/SPI/2009-05-spi-operation-typhoon-1978.md).
• Joe, Map & Counters, “Three Different Designers Look at the Same Battle: SPI Simulates the ’41 Battle for Moscow in 1970, 1972 and 1978”, May 2009.
• Joseph Balkoski, design preview, Moves 36 (Dec 1977/Jan 1978), p. 30.
• SPI “Work in Progress” status reports, S&T 65 (Nov/Dec 1977) p. 18; S&T 66 (Jan/Feb 1978) p. 18; S&T 69 (Jul/Aug 1978) p. 13; S&T 71 (Nov/Dec 1978) p. 19.
• SPI advertisement, S&T 69 (Jul/Aug 1978), p. 3.
• Feedback credits, Moves 46 (Aug/Sep 1979), p. 33; SPI game list, S&T 100, p. 35.
• Friedrich G. Helfferich, “Operation Typhoon: Fury Long Since Spent”, Player’s Notes, Fire & Movement 15 (Feb 1979), from p. 31 (printed), continued later in the issue (PDF pp. 50, 46).
• Brian Laidlaw, “Operation Typhoon — reviewed”, Phoenix 19 (1979), from p. 7 (PDF pp. 8–11).
• Review, “Operation Typhoon”, Wargamer Vol. 1 No. 10, p. 38 (reviewer not identified in the scan).
• David M. Glantz, Barbarossa: Hitler’s Invasion of Russia 1941 (Tempus), pp. 169–189 (printed).
• Osprey Command 22, Georgy Zhukov, pp. 21–22.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.